Michael Colhaze http://www.theoccid April 11, 2010 Every Jew, somewhere in his being, should set apart a zone of hate — healthy virile hate — for what the German personifies and for what persists in the German. Elie Wiesel, Nobel Prize winner and "chief witness" to the Holocaust Those who sow wind will harvest a Tempest. Hosea 8,7 It did not take long and the rumours turned into a thunderclap so deafening that everybody stood benumbed, unable at first to grasp its full impact. Germany had begun to recover amazingly fast. At Nuremberg the Allies did a thorough job and strung up those ringleaders that weren't of further use, while the lesser satraps got locked away or were let off with the proverbial black eye. Something not in store for the German prisoners of war who died by the tens of thousands in Eisenhower's atrocious winter camps or Stalin's monstrous gulags. The propaganda machinery continued for a while at full pelt, presenting Hitler's Germany to the world as a nation of aggressors, gangsters, murderers, barbarians, collaborators and petty criminals, to name but a few, and in short the beastly Hun of old who had fully deserved his terrible fate. History is written by the victors, and even those who knew better clenched their teeth, shrugged, thanked God for their miraculous survival and busied themselves with clearing away the rubble. While those who were already duped into believing their implicit guilt thought it a reasonable price for a full belly and tried to look forward and never backwards again. As the years went by and the ugly Bear behind the Iron Curtain began to growl always louder and more threatening, Germany's strategic importance became paramount. Which required a change of tactics, including an upgrading of the Hun into something like a human being. One that had to be accepted, with much grovelling and tail-wagging from its intellectual quarters, into the Family of Man again. The capitalist edition, naturally. My mother meanwhile had remarried, a union of convenience soon fraught with discord. It did not last long and sadly clouded the most formative period of my youth. She died recently, and the last time I saw her she asked me to take off my shoes and lay by her side. Already on the threshold and fading fast, she saw not the son but his father instead, the only lover of her long, long life. On my occasional visits to one of our great cathedrals I light a candle for both, and pray that they may be united again in a world of pure light, happy as on the day they first met, and their love a pledge that will outlast Eternity. Caspar David Friedrich Summer Oil on Canvas 1807 For a while at least I became part of a real family, and one of its great moments was the arrival of a TV set. I still remember vividly the advent of the ruinous machine, font of utter stupidity, manipulator, death knell of civilisation' A new and more reliable High Priest for the young, they said approvingly, and, with disgust, for the elderly an ersatz magician in lieu of the real one who had blown his brains out only ten years previously. Some news items of those years are still much on my mind. Particularly the day when Sir Winston Churchill received theKarlspreis, or Charlemagne Award, at Aachen in the great Emperor's beautiful chapel that dates back to 800 AD. Which had miraculously survived the combined USAF and RAF onslaught, contrary to countless civilians who had not. I don't know to this day who came up with the idea, if one of those bootlicking, spineless, blathering politicians that are so endemic among modern democracies, or someone with a sardonic touch and a bright mind. Whatever the answer, the old boogie had just been given the boot by his own conservative buddies and was vainglorious enough to accept yet another distinction. Wheezing and shuffling down the long road to extinction, he must have felt positively bemused while observing a Germania redux, its new and somewhat synthetic phoenix rising powerfully from the ashes, whereas his own empire crumbled irreversibly into oblivion. 'It can't be true', whispered my mother as we watched the ghostly pageant in black-and-white. 'This man is responsible for the death of millions! What has happened to the world? Have we all gone mad?!' We have, apparently. Though in those days, and already heavily indoctrinated, I missed the full meaning of her words. Whereas now I don't, particularly after reading Patrick Buchanan's Unnecessary Warand Kevin McDonald's Culture of Critique. Who really boil it down to one single, terrible truth, namely that this man and his paymasters were the instigators not only of the death of Britain's and America's finest young men, but also of the greatest carnage, the worst fratricide committed in Mankind's entire history. It is really here, in the inordinate hate for Germany as the old heartland of our incomparable Christian-European civilisation, that the roots can be found for the ever intensifying assault on the White Man's right to exist. I wonder sometimes how this man must have felt during the twilight years of his life. Terrible, most likely. Fiddling with some pitiful canvas utterly devoid of human warmth, let alone artistic gratification. Abandoned by his old paymasters because that's what they inevitably do once you've lost your expediency. Deserted by his political cronies who knew damn well what mess he had landed them in. Prowling the casinos of Monte Carlo where a greasy Onassis dropped an occasional chip into his pocket since he had blown his pension already at the tables. Bored to death by all the glorifications and laurels and distinctions which honoured, as he himself knew perfectly well, only the one great lie that was his life. And haunted by Agnes the Lamb and millions like her. If the Hereafter could be described as a mirror image of our present deeds and aspirations, their accumulated medium as independent of time and space yet perfectly real, then I prefer to see this man not sizzling in one of Hell's deepest dungeons, but rather in an icy and echoing void where the whole Universe has recoiled into itself, leaving him alone with the terrible truth of his crimes, and the knowledge that whatever hope for redemption he has left must be abandoned, now and forever and into all Eternity. Caspar David Friedrich Sea of Ice Oil on Canvas 1824 The thunderclap came one leisurely evening between supper and a glass of red wine. It was called By Night and Fog and changed my life forever. A documentary, it was called. Whereas in fact it was the testimony of an atrocity so vast that it defied imagination. Six million innocent souls killed in cold blood, with ruthless German efficiency, in the most horrible way possible. Three and a half million in Auschwitz alone. I have never seen the flick again. I couldn't, and now I won't. I don't even remember particular sequences of it. All I can call to mind, in a sort of general way, are mountains of corpses, mountains of shoes, mountains of spectacles. And while I and the country still digested the seismic aftershocks, even worse was to come. Human bodies made into soap, human skin used as lampshades, human skulls boiled down to half their size like those of the Amazonian headhunters. Barbarous SS men smacking new-born babies against a wall. Dr. Mengele conducting unspeakable experiments with small children… A deathly pall fell over the country. Whoever had dared until then to point out the injustice of Versailles that was really the reason for everything in its wake, whoever maintained that Hitler's Germany was not only the dreaded Gestapo and sinister SS but in many ways also amazingly caring and sane and clean, whoever stated that Hitler only wanted to recuperate stolen German land and never sought war except perhaps with Stalin and his murderous gang, fell silent for good. Because whatever had been done to Germany was total peanuts compared with what Germany had done to the Jews. Which was the reason why the land of Bach, Goethe and Kant became for the next fifty years a colony of lepers, openly or secretly despised by everyone except for their money, a commodity they lavished generously on the rest of the world in a timid effort at absolution. My education has been reasonably complete. Added were over the years more languages, simply by living, sometimes for over a decade, in various European countries. I read Byron, Leopardi, Lorca, Villon in the original. I adore them, of course, just as I adore Verdi or Vivaldi. Yet I could never, in a strictly subjective manner, prevent myself from being most awed by the incomparable phalanx of poets, composers, painters, philosophers, mystics and educators my own country has produced over the centuries. There was never any arrogance in this sentiment, though surely a subdued pride. And a deep and continuing sadness, even dread, that the holocaust could have happened in a nation of such intellectual magnificence. Soon I began to feel its effects on a practical level. On my first visit to Amsterdam a young Dutchman told me expansively, in perfect German and with the friendliest smile, of how to get in the quickest possible way to the Central Train Station. I walked for half an hour until I realized that he had sent my into the opposite direction. When I finally arrived, my train was long gone and another one would leave only the next morning. So I stretched out on a bench in the waiting room, ready to pass the night there. But an official came and growled: 'No Nazis here!' I slunk away, and in a quiet street found another bench under a wide tree. When I woke well before sunrise, stiff and cold with an aching back, the resident company of doves had thoroughly splattered my coat with their droppings. In Paris the proprietor of a run-down pension asked me, once the bill was safely paid, if I had been a guard in the Bergen-Belsen concentration camp. In Copenhagen some snotty poof who insisted he was part of young Elton John's entourage wanted to know if my father had been an SS colonel. In Belgrade a woman spat into my face for reasons I can only imagine. And in Cadiz, during my seafaring days, I got into a fight with some Swedes who taunted me for once beyond endurance. Which left the pub in shambles, the Swedes on the floor and me with a black eye and three front teeth missing. Plus a night in jail and a heavy fine. Whereby the latter, to my great relief, was revoked after I had lisped my version of events to the Captain of Guardia Civil in charge. Keeping it in a nutshell, Germany's glorious history had been reduced to a mere twelve years of unspeakable barbarity. Attempts at damage limitation were of course underway, like outing Hitler and his gang as Germanically atypical, him a heathen Austrian at that. But whenever I stated in some foreign parts my name and nationality, I saw the minute hesitation, felt the slight inner recoil, and knew perfectly well what people were thinking. To tell the truth, and as the years went by, and me not being timid or over-sentimental in any case, it didn't bother me too much. I began to know my own worth, and screw those who refused to recognize it. But as a result, the ugly German in me, and on the whole in many of my compatriots, tried always to be marginally more upright and just and honest than everybody else, even more forgiving. Which, not surprisingly, served us well in the long run. Only recently, after many a year, I revisited one of my old haunts high up in some Spanish mountains where I had spent nearly a decade and employed half the village in a varying and often hazardous enterprise. The warmth and simple joy I was received with made me swallow hard and wrestle down an aberrant tear. In my early twenties, while roaming through Europe by way of hitchhiking, I hung out for a few days in one of Rome's many youth hostels. As the usual soiree of cheap Chianti and even cheaper Grappa got into full swing, a Jewish gentleman of Eastern provenance approached me and asked for a favour. He had twinkling little eyes, an uncommonly large and bulbous nose, high blood pressure, an ample midriff and must have been about seventy five years old. I fell of course over my own feet to accommodate him. His English was atrocious, and it took me some time to understand that he was on his way to Germany and needed a letter of introduction. Or better, a document that would help him to claim indemnifications. What for, I asked appalled, fearing immediately the worst. A good question, he conceded, and wanted to know if I had any suggestions. So we sat down and cooked up a story whose details I don't remember anymore, but would probably blush crimson if they were read to me today. Rounding it off, he needed a name, since his was acoustically too cumbersome, too long and too Cyrillic in any case. As an experienced cosmopolitan I suggested Cohen, which for unclear reasons didn't sit well with him. After some deliberations I came up with Germany's foremost nonsense poet, and thus Mr. Morningstar was born. I hope he achieved his aims, continued to shine brilliantly, and lived happily ever after. When all was done, he patted my cheek approvingly and said: 'Son! You are a good Nazi!' Which left me, historically speaking, with the profound satisfaction that there must have been at least one of those in the whole wide world. Nazi, then. A label that became, like an unspecified threadworm, part of my inner make-up. It lurked at the back of my head, needed only one of the many catchwords to spring to attention, and haunted me sometimes in my dreams. As to the catchwords, Germany began practically to drown in them. Nourished by the war's spineless intellectual leftovers and their aforementioned paymasters who had crept into every strata of the burgeoning media, they soon became a perverse gutter creed that secretly and intentionally challenged the established religion. It scuttled and hunkered wherever you looked, jumped onto your back in the most inappropriate moments, and snapped at your heels when you knelt down for a moment of silent prayer. To prop it up a giant and worldwide propaganda avalanche was launched in clearly predictable intervals, flaunting yet another horror story that had so far been overlooked by the prostrate historians. Which ended inevitably with the payment of yet another billion of German taxpayers' money to some holocaust victims' great-grandparents, great-grandchildren As for myself, it took nearly fifty years until the first doubts began to appear. Doubts as hideous as the certainties that had beset me formost of my life. Left: Auschwitz (Original Photo); Right: Auschwitz (Wiesenthal Centre Rendering) Michael Colhaze (email him) is a pen name. Permanent URL:http://www.theoccid

To be a German (Part 2)


--
Peace.
Michael Santomauro
Editorial Director
Call anytime: 917-974-6367
ReporterNotebook@
Apr 11, 2010
To Be German
Apr 10, 2010
Thought provoking -
| and it is well worthy of worldwide distribution. You need a reason to do so? Ask Israel or those who have hijacked the American and British governments if they would like to see its distribution. If not; there then is your reason to place it as far and wide as possible. |
Peace.
Michael Santomauro
Editorial Director
Call anytime: 917-974-6367
ReporterNotebook@
Amazon's: DEBATING THE HOLOCAUST: A New Look At Both Sides by Thomas Dalton
Mondoweiss
Mondoweiss |
- A 'constellation of Jewish groups' (J Street to David Project) seeks to block any accountability for cruel occupation
- The lobby squirts squid-ink at Steve Walt
- Neocon offers disinformation about Occupation in 'LA Times'
- The Cooper Union question: Was Arab anti-Semitism the same as Nazi anti-Semitism?
- Neocons take over Buckley's inheritance
- Ambushing the ambiguity
- J'aime Paul Berman beaucoups
- Is the US getting ready to push Israel to declare its nuclear status?
- Brave Palestinian journalist arrested for filming protests
- Blau-Kamm case exposes the dark underbelly of Israel's security state
| Posted: 10 Apr 2010 09:16 AM PDT The battle is joined inside the Jewish community over boycott/divestment/ A coalition of nearly 20 Jewish groups, ranging from the right-wing David Project and the Jewish National Fund to the liberal J Street, is distributing a misleading statement condemning a Student Senate bill at UC Berkeley. The ground-breaking bill calls for divestment from companies that profit from the perpetuation of the Israeli military occupation in the West Bank (including East Jerusalem) and Gaza. They refer to the bill as "dishonest" and "misleading" and "based on contested allegations."
/In fact, the Berkeley bill was co-authored by an Israeli Jewish student on campus and is supported by many Jews who have testified in favor of the bill and have written thousands of letters of support to the student senators. Then, a similar coalition accused the Presbyterian Church of "one-sidedness" and in much more explicit terms, anti-Semitism. In other words, they re-cast the very idea that one should be "invested only in peaceful pursuits" in Israel-Palestine as biased or racist. Sydney Levy is the Director of Campaigns for Jewish Voice for Peace, a national grassroots organization dedicated to full equality between Israelis and Palestinians. Yaman Salahi, a UC Berkeley alumnus and member of Students for Justice in Palestine, is currently a student at Yale Law School. |
| The lobby squirts squid-ink at Steve Walt Posted: 10 Apr 2010 08:54 AM PDT This is a good fight. Robert Satloff of the Washington Institute for Near East Policy adopts an Alfred-E-Newman like cluelessness in saying, What possible attachments to foreign countries can Steve Walt be talking about--Morocco? Jordan? Turkey?--when he criticizes the Washington Institute and Dennis Ross, who once worked there before going to the Obama administration. As if Satloff does not care about Israel in the morning and in the afternoon and at night too. Walt responds calmly that he is talking of course about attachments to Israel, but that he doesn't use the word "dual loyalty" because we all have multiple identities in this modern age (well some of us). He says it's a straightforward question of conflict of interest and describes WINEP's pedigree as the spawn of AIPAC:
The last point may be the best one. People are waking up, and this is pretty straightforward. Someone who was head of the Jewish People Policy Planning Institute in Jerusalem, warning against intermarriage in the U.S.--Dennis Ross--shouldn't be guiding our Iran policy. And why is he? Because of the lobby. I like the dual loyalty concept. So does Eric Alterman of the Nation. So too does John Judis of the New Republic. It gets at the matter of Jewish nationality that Zionists sought to create in an era of nationalism. And today when Israeli interest and American interest are so wildly divergent, it is a big issue. A year back in a reflective moment, Jeffrey Goldberg said that the Iran issue gave him conflict on this very question. His love for Israel conflicted with the interests of the U.S. I wonder the same about Tariq Ramadan's Muslim religion and Swiss nationality. Swiss when I vote, Ramadan said the other night; but there wasn't another Swiss moment all night. The American public, the American elite, deserve this discussion of religion and the Middle East, conducted with sincerity. |
| Neocon offers disinformation about Occupation in 'LA Times' Posted: 10 Apr 2010 08:34 AM PDT Anonymous writes: I think you've followed Robert Pape's work quite closely. It is very important. Neocon Max Boot has now taken it up in the LA Times:
His error here has to do with his misrepresentation of the barrier as being "along the West Bank" when everybody paying attention should know that the vast majority of it is inside the West Bank. To say "along" without also saying "inside" is to misrepresent reality and mislead readers.I haven't even got into his use of the term "targeted operations." Those targeted operations killed 47 innocent bystanders in 2003, while 44 actual targets were killed. That's hardly a "targeted" result when there's such "collateral" damage. I wonder if some of this knowledge motivated Anat Kamm. From the State Department. |
| The Cooper Union question: Was Arab anti-Semitism the same as Nazi anti-Semitism? Posted: 09 Apr 2010 09:30 PM PDT Last night at Cooper Union, George Packer sought to expose some possibly embarrassing sources of Tariq Ramadan's political commitments by reading a quotation from Ramadan's grandfather, Hassan al-Banna, the founder of the Muslim Brotherhood. Packer asked Ramadan why he had failed to address the import of such anti-Semitic utterances; he implied that the failure might indicate a less than candid approach, by Ramadan, to Islamic anti-Semitism generally. Ramadan said that the quotation seemed to him likely to have been taken out of context. Packer insisted that the only relevant context was what it must have meant to ally oneself with an ally of Hitler. Packer incidentally acknowledged that he had drawn his quotation from a recent book by Jeffrey Herf, Nazi Propaganda for the Arab World. That source, however, has, in fact, come under strong criticism precisely for its practice of de-contextualizatio
|
| Neocons take over Buckley's inheritance Posted: 09 Apr 2010 09:21 PM PDT The neocon takeover of NRO is complete: "Petraeus's Israel Problem." WF Buckley Jr., who opposed the war in Iraq, must be turning in his grave. And Pamela Geller the fevered Israel devotee writes that Petraeus is pushing "jihadist rhetoric of Islamic anti-semitism." Wow who would have believed that Petraeus was a stealth Islamist. |
| Posted: 09 Apr 2010 09:12 PM PDT Like the gleeful sound one makes upon hearing that a particularly obnoxious and troublesome relative will not be attending a family gathering, Washington officials probably issued a collective sigh of relief when hearing the news that Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu has cancelled his visit to Washington planned for next week. The Israeli Prime Minister has caused enough diplomatic problems for the Obama government recently and his appearance at an international summit on the spread of nuclear weapons could have further embarrassed both Israel and the United States. Netanyahu will not attend the weapons conference because he is afraid to confront a group of representatives of Muslim and Arab nations who plan to bring up the issue of Israel's non-participation in the Non-Proliferation Treaty. These nations want to force Israel to publicly acknowledge its nuclear capability and permit international inspection of its facilities. The Jerusalem Post refers to the Israeli nuclear arsenal as "alleged," maintaining the ludicrous Tel Aviv "policy of ambiguity." The headline of the Hebrew version of Ynet says Netanyahu is afraid of an "ambush" by the Arab delegates to the conference. Israel will send Intelligence Minister Dan Meridor to the conference to be the flak-catcher for Netanyahu. The Israeli leader's absence will deflect attention from the potential bad publicity that discussion of Israel's nuclear capability will generate. Israel maintains an arsenal that is assumed to be between 100 and 300 warheads depending on the source of the data estimate. Mordechai Vanunu revealed details of Israel's nuclear arsenal to the British press in 1986. He served 18 years in an Israeli prison after being abducted from Italy by the Israeli intelligence service Mossad. Vanunu is prohibited from leaving Israel, where his freedom of speech, association and movement have been severely limited by authorities since his release. He has been designated as a prisoner of conscience by Amnesty International. According to the Federation of American Scientists website, it has been reported that "fearing defeat in the October 1973 Yom Kippur War, the Israelis assembled 13 twenty-kiloton atomic bombs." The fact that Israel may have seriously considered a nuclear strike in 1973 first became known to the general public in Seymour Hersh's 1993 book, The Samson Option. If my memory serves me, Hersh claimed that Israel loaded the nukes on missiles and aimed them. Surely the Americans must be ecstatic about Netanyahu not coming for another visit, although they are forced by their "very special relationship" with Israel to explicitly deny the obvious. The dubious honor for the denial fell on the shoulders of national security adviser General James Jones, who told reporters that "of course we wanted the Prime Minister [Netanyahu] to come [back for another visit]." Isn't the very special Israeli-American relationship getting more special all the time? |
| Posted: 09 Apr 2010 07:35 PM PDT From Ron Rosenbaum at Slate:
Mais oui, the clarity that he demonstrated when he defended the assault on Gaza's civilian population under the rubric of fighting anti-Semitism. Though in his defense he had been silent on the siege of Gaza.
Does this apply to Israel? Should we tolerate an intolerant polity or state? Is there a tribalism that is masked by his high-falutin Enlightenment talk that privileges his tribe over a neighbouring tribe? The answer is once again: mais oui. J'aime Paul Berman, c'est un pompous windbag who personifies the decline of what passes for intellectual discourse in late imperial America. |
| Is the US getting ready to push Israel to declare its nuclear status? Posted: 09 Apr 2010 12:06 PM PDT Whatever else can be said about the strained relationship between Barack Obama and Benjamin Netanyahu, one thing is clear: Obama seems intent on keeping Netanyahu off balance. On Tuesday, Netanyahu announced he would be returning to Washington next week to attend Obama's Nuclear Security Summit. Just days later, he had changed his mind, ostensibly because of "fears that a group of Muslim states, led by Egypt and Turkey, would demand that Israel sign up to the international Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty, or NPT," Haaretz reported. An earlier report in the Jerusalem Post, however, had raised that specific issue and said this would not deter the Israeli prime minister from attending the summit:
Earlier, Ynet reported:
It's unclear however, whether the administration' The United States is not on the brink of pushing Israel to sign the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty, but it could be signalling its willingness to see pressure applied by others as it provides a platform in Washington for such an effort. Moreover, in a little noted move, the Obama administration appears to be using a new diplomatic tool to signal that Israel's days of "nuclear ambiguity" may be numbered: Israel's nuclear scientists are now being shut out of the United States. A report on the Hebrew NRG/Maariv website, under a headline, Dimona reactor workers not welcome in the US, says that workers at Israel's Dimona nuclear research reactor who submitted visa requests to visit the United States for ongoing university education in physics, chemistry and nuclear engineering, have all been rejected, specifically because of their association with the Dimona reactor. According to the report, this is a new policy decision by the Obama administration, since reactor workers were until recently being issued visas to study in the US. This is cross-posted from Woodward's site, War in Context. |
| Brave Palestinian journalist arrested for filming protests Posted: 09 Apr 2010 09:54 AM PDT The latest news from Bil'in: Haitham Al Khatib was arrested while filming at today's demonstration, held on the anniversary of the Deir Yassin massacre. Details below. I'm reminded of the story Haitham told me when I asked about the deep scar between his eyebrows. The thing to keep in mind is that all of the soldiers know Haitham and Hamde Abo, the Bil'in photographer: they are the dynamic duo that arrives on scene to document each and every night raid. It's the same soldiers day in and day out, so Haitham and Hamde can recognize familiar eyes and mouths beneath the masks. (This is how Hamde describes the faces of the IDF: "I know the soldiers like my brother.") So one day Haitham was taking photographs at the weekly demonstration. A soldier told Haitham to stop, or else: he'd shoot him in the head. Haitham didn't stop, and so the soldier shot him between the eyes with a rubber-coated steel bullet, fracturing his skull. When Haitham was released from the hospital, he was back at the wall each Friday with his camera–just as he'll be back at the wall when or if he's ever released from Israeli military detention. Hamde Abo reports:
|
| Blau-Kamm case exposes the dark underbelly of Israel's security state Posted: 09 Apr 2010 08:01 AM PDT What is misleadingly being called in Israel the "Anat Kamm espionage affair" is quickly revealing the dark underbelly of a nation that has worshipped for decades at the altar of a security state.
|
--
Peace.
Michael Santomauro
Editorial Director
Call anytime: 917-974-6367
ReporterNotebook@
Amazon's: DEBATING THE HOLOCAUST: A New Look At Both Sides by Thomas Dalton
From Gilad: 3 very important videos
1.Mohammed Omer (Rafah Today) with Amy Goodman (Democracy Now)
Peace.
Michael Santomauro
Editorial Director
Call anytime: 917-974-6367
ReporterNotebook@
Amazon's: DEBATING THE HOLOCAUST: A New Look At Both Sides by Thomas Dalton
