Kevin MacDonald: A recent panel discussion of Quentin Tarantino's Inglourious Basterds had some interesting tidbits about Jewish revenge fantasies: But [Dr. Amy] Kalmanofsky quickly put that argument [that Jews should feel guilty about revenge] to bed, noting that Jewish texts have always embraced revenge fantasies, from the destruction of the Egyptians in Exodus and Haman & Co. in Megillat Esther. And [Rabbi Jack] Moline — echoing the message of one of his Yom Kippur sermons from earlier this year — also praised the film, describing it as a way of helping American Jews shed some of their Holocaust baggage and getting more comfortable with their Zionist sides. Moline told his congregants: "To my surprise, my complete and utter surprise, there was something cathartic and deeply satisfying watching this revenge fantasy play out. It was as if something I did not dare admit — my secret blood lust to do unto them what they did unto us — was being acknowledged, permitted and validated. I was liberated from victim hood." For making Jews feel good about their blood lust, Tarantino's future in Hollywood is assured. The producer, Lawrence Bender, told Tarantino"Quentin you are about to make your Bar Mitzvah movie, you are going to be officially let into the tribe." This reminds me of Alison Weir's wonderful recent article "Israeli Organ Trafficing and Theft: From Palestine to Moldova." She discusses the work of Prof. Nancy Scheper-Hughes of the University of California-Berkeley Scheper-Hughes discussed the two motivations of Israeli traffickers. One was greed, she said. The other was somewhat chilling: "Revenge, restitution – reparation for the Holocaust." She described speaking with Israeli brokers who told her "it's kind of 'an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth. We're going to get every single kidney and liver and heart that we can. The world owes it to us.'" Scheper-Hughes says that she "even heard doctors saying that." I think that revenge fantasies are a common among Jews and it goes way beyond Nazis. In "Memories of Madison" I wrote that In my experience at Madison during the 1960s, there was also a strong desire [among Jews] for bloody, apocalyptic revenge against the entire social structure—perceived by them to be the goyish, fascist, capitalist, racist, anti-Semitic social structure. … This fits well with the set of interviews with New Left Jewish radicals in Percy Cohen's Jewish Radicals and Radical Jews: many had destructive fantasies in which the revolution would result in "humiliation, dispossession, imprisonment or execution of the oppressors." These fantasies of destruction of the social order were combined with a belief in their own omnipotence and their ability to create a non-oppressive social order. As Whites become a minority in Western societies and Jews constitute a hostile elite, this Jewish focus on revenge has grave implications for the future. Revenge becomes an important issue given that Jews tend to interpret their history of living among Europeans as a long series of persecutions beginning with Christianity and ending with the Holocaust. (See, e.g., Norman Podhoretz's Why are Jews Liberals?.) Tags: Kevin MacDonald Kevin MacDonald: Jewish Revenge Fantasies
Michael Santomauro
Editorial Director
Call anytime: 917-974-6367
New Release: Debating The Holocaust by Thomas Dalton
No comments:
Post a Comment