Here are the headlines from Mondoweiss for 09/13/2010:
- A Jordanian complains about his king and the Zionists
- 91 year old, and his grandson, among three farm workers killed by Israeli shells in Gaza
- On 9/11 anniversary, Park 51 Islamic center sparks rallies, for and against
- After Birthright: 'We're not stereotypes'
- Injustice is Injustice
A Jordanian complains about his king and the Zionists
Sep 13, 2010 03:49 am | Philip WeissThe other night in Jordan my wife and I ate at a fancy place and when the bill came, I had to walk off to the cash machine to get more money.
When I got back my wife was sitting with the restaurateur and two of his friends drinking tea and having a political conversation. The men were complaining about King Abdullah of Jordan. The night before the king's brother had had a wedding in the desert. 15 million dinar ($22 million). Earlier this year the queen had had a birthday. 10 million dinar. Then the queen was off to Italy to help the poor children of Italy. There are no poor children here?
I was excited to hear Jordanians complaining about their king. They spoke English well, they were sophisticated men. I sat on a plastic chair that a boy brought over.
The king doesn't care about his people. There is a layer of rich people and then nothing, and then there are the common people. Many make 3-500 dinar a month. But it takes 1000 dinar a month to live in this country.
I said, What will it take to change that? The restaurateur said, "Obama can change it, maybe."
In that moment, the conversation made a sudden turn.
I felt he was saying that Obama was propping the king up to support Israel and that only when American support for Israel changed would the corrupt dictatorships of the Arab world begin to loosen.
I said, "Do you think Obama can bring middle east peace?"
The man made a face. "No. He canot. No one can do that."
Why not? "When someone takes your land and your house, and make you flee, and they rape your mother and kill your sister, do you think that you can forget that? No. No one can forget that."
Besides, he went on, there was a difference between the Palestinians in the 67 territories and the ones in the 48 territories. In the 48, they are relatively comfortable, they can make money. But in the 67 it is a prison. You know, he went on, Netanyahu is more powerful than Obama. "Because what is the most powerful thing in the world, money. And who has the most money? The Jews. So Netanyahu doesn't have to do anything he doesn't want."
I said, "But Abdullah and 'Asad just met in Damascus and said that they would accept Israel on the 67 lines. The Arab League has said the same. Why isn't that possible?"
My wife stood up. "Phil I'm gong tback to the hotel." She finds political conversations boring. I told her to wait a minute.
He said, "No one can make a peace. God can't make a peace. Besides, there are too many people making money off the situation."
And after that we shook hands and left.
A few comments: I went to Jordan to learn more about the Arab context of the problem. And it is interesting that this man has a more sophisticated understanding of the root of the problem than most people in the United States, when he speaks so feelingly of the Arab dispossession and persecution of the Palestinians. Few people in the U.S. are aware of these things. Even though Brown scholar Glenn Loury talks about the Nakba on bloggingheads.tv, this is a minority understanding. If you read Michael Beschloss's book on great presidential decisions or Robert Kaplan's book on The Arabists, you will find that the creation of Israel is described as a great liberal advance. But it wasn't a liberal advance. It was solving a European problem with a colonial enterprise that resolved itself with ethnic cleansing. The ethnic cleansing is remembered and resented across the Arab world. The Israelis thought that they could merely push the problem away, and they still think that, but it has haunted them.
The conversation reminds me of why I am for the right of return. Because it is way overdue, because as Gideon Levy says in his column that Adam quoted here the other day, it is the soul of the issue, because it is right, because it is about respect, because the U.N. demanded it again and again and again, and because it would heal more than anything else would heal. These old grievances must be dealt with. There is only one way to put them aside, acknowledgment, apology, compensation. And yes, restoration of villages and homes when people wish to return (without eviction).
The description of Jewish power will strike many people as anti-Semitic. And I guess it is; certainly it is imprecise and makes gross generalizations about a group of people. Some years ago Tom Friedman (who is rich as Croesus) spluttered that the Arab world is filled with conspiracy theories; surely he meant talk like this. While it is true that I should have said to the man that I am Jewish, (my wife was impatient, I wanted to ask him if he was Palestinian and didn't), I would just point out that his statement is consistent with, a, Seymour Hersh saying on Amy Goodman that the Iran bombing push is about "Jewish money" in the political system, b, MJ Rosenberg saying recently that Netanyahu has more power in Congress than Obama does, again because of election contributions/the lobby, c, Juan Cole saying that neoconservative ideas persist because half of the Fortune 400 billionaires are neocons (which yes is shorthand for rightwing Jews), d, Netanyahu saying, in a recently discovered video from ten years back, that the U.S. is "something that can be easily moved" (or similar words; lousy internet connection here). I have always said that an honest descripton of how much money Jews bring into the political process is necessary if we are going to straighten this issue out. Denying Jewish power is an intellectual dodge--yes, one widely undertaken to prevent another Holocaust. Well sorry it's not helping.
The conversation gave me a sense of purpose. Zionism created this thoughtful man's rage. Which, yes, is shared across the Arab world. This grievance must be answered. Only madmen want to strip Jews of power in western societies. Jewish power is just the flavor of the elite these days, the meritocratic culture of the west. The idea is to change Jews. Young Jews, liberal Jews, aware Jews, empowered Jews, universalist Jews, led by people like Lynn Gottlieb and Rebecca Vilkomerson, freely acknowledge the man's grievance and are working to change the Jewish adherence to Zionism. That is the most productive work I can do.
Comment on this article >
91 year old, and his grandson, among three farm workers killed by Israeli shells in Gaza
Sep 13, 2010 01:09 am | Adie MormechWhen 91 year old Ibrahim Abu Sayed left his home this morning to check on his land and animals by the remains of his old house, he took with him his 17 year old grandson Hossam and his friend and neighbour Ismail Abu Oda, who was 16. His son and Hossam's father didn't want to come because it was the final day of EID, the muslim celebration that follows Ramadan.
Despite his age, Ibrahim Abu Sayed was still mobile enough to regularly check his three dunums of land, as he had done for decades, the last decade being the hardest as his house was destroyed in 2000 by Israeli bulldozers and his rebuilt house destroyed in the three-week attacks by Israel on Gaza over the new year of 2009.
But early Saturday evening would be the last time Ibrahim, Hossam and Ismail would work their land. 700 metres from the border where their land was located, north of Sharab street, Israeli tanks made an incursion into Gaza. The grandfather, his grandson and friend did not stand a chance as the tanks fired shells directly at them.
We met the family members at the hospital. The wife of Ibrahim was devastated, screaming in horror at the fate that had befallen her family.
"I was there half an hour before it happened", said Mohammed Abu Oda, another relative. "I saw them by their sheep. I heard the shells from the Israeli tanks, the shells we learned soon afterwards had killed our relatives."
They were killed instantly, and according to the doctor (who wished to remain anonymous) who examined once they had arrived at Beit Hanoun hospital. Ibrahim suffered severe shrapnel injuries to his face, chest and stomach and his grandson Hossam had the back of his head blown away. We verified this immediately as we saw the mutilated bodies in the morgue. Ismail, the friend of Hossam, had arrived at the hospital 30 minutes after the others but had been buried before we got there; most part of his head was shot away. The boys were close friends, studying in the 9th and 10th grade respectively, and had expected to return to school the following day after Eid.
But on that day they still were on holidays, so they helped Ibrahim, like they were used to do. Because despite of having faced their hardest times, after their house was destroyed and their land bulldozed, the bedouin family still had no other job other than farming. Although they were obliged to farm their land close to the border, it was still far enough away to be outside the Israeli imposed "buffer zone"
"Israel claims that there's a three hundred meter buffer zone, but they were 700 meters far from the border", said an Uncle of Ismail, Majdy Abu Oda. "The people there are farmers who've been living there for years. We, the people here, were never dangerous for the Israelis. They have photos of the people who live and work here, the area is full off observation cameras. So they knew them."
That was why the family considered themselves to be safe, even though there were tanks at the border. But they paid with their lives for that. More victims of Israel's 'collective punishment', a crime against humanity according to article 33 of the Geneva Convention of which Israel is a signatory member.
So a 91 year old man, his grandson and a friend of his were killed while tending to their livestock on their own farm, 700 metres from the border with Israel. Where is the clamour for justice? Where is the international outrage that at least should be comparable to the Israeli settlers shot a week ago, who actually were not settled on their own land according to international law? Israeli armed forces have continued to wage a war against civilians in Gaza, long after the Israeli air and ground assault in the winter of 2008/2009.
With the family clearly posing no threat, and known as long term residents of the area, there is little imagination required to understand the ease with which these Israeli soldiers felt they could kill these three men with impunity, once their livelihood had already been destroyed.
Saber Zaneen General Coordinator of the Beit Hanoun solidarity group, 'Local Initiative' released a callout for justice in a statement:
"Today the occupation committed a new crime which will be added to its black list. Three martyrs now rest in heaven after the shelling an again we call on the international community and civil society to pressure the occupation forces to stop such crimes against Palestinian civilians and to start working on giving some protection to the local people in the Gaza Strip."
Adie Mormech is a human rights advocate based in the Gaza Strip who was previously abducted by the Israeli navy from the eighth Free Gaza Movement boat, the Spirit of Humanity. He volunteers with the International Solidarity Movement.
Comment on this article >
On 9/11 anniversary, Park 51 Islamic center sparks rallies, for and against
Sep 12, 2010 04:59 pm | Alex Kane and Ellen Davidson
__._,_.___MARKETPLACE
No comments:
Post a Comment